Imagine owning an entire island on Lake Muskoka, and having the freedom to create what comes next. Cedar Island is an extraordinary approx. 3.5 acre private island sanctuary, beautifully positioned within the prestigious West Beaumaris corridor and surrounded by the iconic landmarks of Old Woman and Stonewall Islands. Family held for over 130 years, this storied property presents a rare opportunity to take an exceptional natural setting and reimagine it as a completely bespoke Muskoka estate. The island's remarkable topography offers a collection of spectacular building sites amongst towering pine and hardwood forests, granite outcroppings and sandy shoreline. Sheltered coves invite morning swims, while rocky points capture sweeping lake vistas and dramatic sunset skies. With panoramic water views and exposures stretching from sunrise to sunset, Cedar Island offers an extraordinary foundation for a sophisticated new Lakehouse and private family compound. Three existing summer cottages offer a connection to the island's past, while the next owner has the opportunity to thoughtfully craft its future. Whether envisioned as a minimalist architectural retreat, an expansive multi-generational lake house or an intimate private sanctuary, there is an unparalleled sense of freedom that comes with owning the entire island. An opportunity for a Walker's Point slip offers easy mainland access while still being 2 hours from North Toronto. Rarely does Lake Muskoka present the opportunity to acquire an entire island with this much privacy, provenance and potential. Cedar Island is your blank canvas, and the chance to build something truly extraordinary.
Address
1 Cedar Island
List Price
$3,095,000
MLS® Status
New
Property Type
Residential Freehold
Type of Dwelling
Detached
Style of Home
Other
Transaction Type
Sale
Area
Muskoka Lakes
Sub-Area
Wood (Muskoka Lakes)
Region
Muskoka
Bedrooms
2
Bedrooms (Total)
2
Rooms Above Grade
6
Bathrooms
1
Floor Area
700-1100 Sq. Ft.
Lot Size Source
MPAC
Lot Size Range (Acres)
2 - 4.99
Lot Size Units
Feet
Lot Width
1916
Parcel Number
480330423
Occupant Type
Owner
Cross Street
Lake Muskoka
MLS® Number
X13190574
Listing Brokerage
Chestnut Park Real Estate
| Johnston & Daniel Rushbrooke Realty
Basement Area
None
Postal Code
P0B 1J0
Posession Details
Flexible
Tax Amount
$11,264.76
Tax Year
2025
Site Influences
Waterfront
Interior Features
Storage
Central Vacuum
No
Family Room
No
Ensuite Laundry
No
Special Designation
Unknown
Standard Status
Active
Disclosures
Unknown
Senior Community
No
Board Or Association
One Point Association of REALTORS
Heat Source
Other
Heat Type
Other
Cooling Features
None
Construction Materials
Cedar, Metal/Steel Siding
Direction Faces
South
Fireplace
No
Foundation Details
Block, Steel Frame
Garage
No
Garage Type
None
Kitchens Total
1
Kitchens Above Grade
1
Pool Features
None
Roof
Metal, Shingles
Tax Legal Description
1 M 87 Cedar Island in Lake Muskoka Wood; Muskoka Lakes
Topography
Sloping, Wooded/Treed
View Type
Water, Trees/Woods, Lake
Water View
Direct
Waterfront
Yes
Docking Type
Private
Waterfront
Direct
Waterfront Accessory
Not Applicable
Waterfront Features
Dock, Island
Water Frontage (Feet)
579
Water Body Name
Lake Muskoka
Water Body Type
Lake
Shoreline
Clean, Deep, Sandy
Shoreline Allowance
Owned
Access To Property
Private Docking
Alternative Power
Unknown
Sewer
Septic